Thinking about contesting a trust? Maybe you feel something's not right, or you believe you were unfairly left out. Perhaps someone pressured the person who made the trust, leading to an outcome that seems unjust. You might wonder - What are the chances of successfully contesting a trust, anyway? What does it even take to challenge a trust and possibly change the distribution of trust assets?

It's important to remember that the chances of successfully contesting a trust aren't very high. Courts typically lean towards upholding a trust unless given compelling reasons not to. It's not about whether a trust beneficiary feels slighted, but whether there are significant legal grounds to overturn what the trust outlines. For example, you would likely need to demonstrate a lack of mental capacity or that the trust settlor was taken advantage of during the estate planning process.

Table of Contents:

• Understanding Trusts and Trust Contests
• Grounds for Contesting a Trust
  • Lack of Capacity
  • Undue Influence
  • Fraud
  • Forgery
  • Mistakes
• The Challenge of Contesting a Trust
• Navigating a Trust Contest
• Conclusion

Understanding Trusts and Trust Contests

A trust is a legal document designed to manage assets. The grantor sets aside specific property, whether it's money, real estate, or other valuables, to be held by a trustee. This trustee then manages those assets according to the instructions laid out in the trust document, distributing them to designated people or organizations known as beneficiaries.

It's a way to control your legacy and make sure your wishes are carried out even when you're gone. This is often seen as a way to avoid probate court, passing your assets to loved ones more directly. It can also help minimize estate taxes and protect your assets from creditors.

A trust contest comes into play when someone believes this carefully constructed system isn't working as it should. They might allege things weren't done properly, the trust's creator was taken advantage of, or that the document doesn't accurately reflect their true wishes. This is when a trust litigation attorney can be helpful.

Grounds for Contesting a Trust

If you're thinking of challenging a trust, understanding the acceptable reasons, or "grounds" for contesting, is vital. These aren't light matters to be taken lightly, especially when dealing with the complexities of a revocable trust or an irrevocable trust. You'll need solid evidence to support your claims, demonstrating not just dissatisfaction with the outcome but genuine legal grounds for overturning the trust.

Some common grounds for contesting a trust include:

Lack of Capacity

This questions whether the person making the trust (the grantor) was mentally sound when they signed the documents. This doesn't mean a momentary lapse of judgment. It dives deeper, often requiring medical records or testimony demonstrating they lacked the ability to fully grasp what they were agreeing to. This is a key concept in estate litigation.

Undue Influence

Imagine a scenario where someone close to the grantor – a caregiver, a relative, maybe even a new romantic partner – uses their position to manipulate the grantor's decisions regarding the trust. The courts take undue influence seriously, scrutinizing if someone took advantage of a vulnerable person for their benefit, ultimately undermining the grantor's true desires. The presence of a no-contest clause can make this even more challenging.

Fraud

This hinges on deception. Did someone lie or intentionally mislead the grantor during the trust creation? Was information hidden that, had the grantor known, would have changed their decision? These questions cut to the core of whether the trust was created with honest intent. If you suspect fraud, consulting with an experienced estate planning attorney is essential. They can guide you on how to gather evidence and navigate the legal complexities involved.

Forgery

This one is straightforward – was the signature on the trust document faked? If the grantor didn't sign the document themselves, or if they were tricked into signing something else under false pretenses, it throws the entire validity of the trust into question. Forgery allegations are taken seriously in legal contexts because of the potential for exploitation and manipulation.

Mistakes

Even with the best intentions, errors can creep into legal documents like estate planning documents. Sometimes the wording might not accurately reflect the grantor's desires, or essential details could be omitted. This ground for contesting is less about ill intent and more about ensuring the trust truly reflects the wishes of its creator.

California law outlines situations like undue influence as reasons to challenge a trust, underscoring their seriousness. This is particularly relevant when dealing with trust disputes and estate administration.

The Challenge of Contesting a Trust

Trusts can be tough to break. This is because unlike wills, which are usually drafted closer to the end of a person's life, a trust is something the grantor often sets up years, maybe even decades, before their death. They live with it, manage their assets according to its terms, and may even adjust it as their life changes. This creates a stronger presumption of validity for the trust, making it more difficult to contest.

For those without an attorney, the chances of successfully contesting a trust often have less than a 33% success rate. This emphasizes that courts take trusts seriously and won't undo them without strong justification and clear evidence.

Consulting with a trust contest lawyer is essential to understand the specific requirements in your jurisdiction and the likelihood of success in your case.

Navigating a Trust Contest

If you're considering this path, know this: it's complex and can be emotionally charged. You'll need the expertise of a proven lawyer to guide you through the process, which often involves navigating the probate process and understanding complex legal concepts such as intestate succession. They can help you build a strong case, gather evidence, and represent your interests in court.

If you've got serious concerns about a trust, talking to an experienced attorney specializing in trust litigation is a good first step. They can help you understand your state's specific laws, assess the strength of your case, and guide you through the process. They can also give you an idea of the potential costs involved, as these types of legal battles can get expensive quickly.

Conclusion

Deciding to contest a trust is not something to rush into lightly. The chances of successfully contesting a trust often hinge on specific, legally-recognized reasons like undue influence, fraud, lack of capacity, and the presence of solid evidence to support the claim. Factors that can influence your chances of success include the type of trust (revocable trust vs. irrevocable trust), the clarity of the trust document, and the presence of a no-contest clause.

Seeking help from a legal professional specializing in estate planning and trust litigation is crucial. They can analyze your situation, determine if you have valid grounds to contest the trust, and guide you on the best course of action. Whether you're a surviving spouse, a sibling contesting a will, or a non-beneficiary with concerns about the trust administration, a consultation with a lawyer experienced in estate litigation is invaluable.

Call or fill out our form to receive help from our proven estate planning attorneys today.