Blog/News

What is Business Litigation? Navigating Disputes

Posted by Darrell P. White | Aug 19, 2024 | 0 Comments

Attorneys in court for business litigation

What is business litigation? It's resolving business disputes through the court system. These legal disputes could involve anything from breach of contract claims and fiduciary duty issues to partnership disputes and even intellectual property infringement.

Successfully resolving legal issues through business litigation requires a strong grasp of legal nuances. A deep understanding of how different types of litigation cases unfold is also essential. Let's take a look at some common situations that often lead to litigation in the business world.

Table of Contents:

Contractual Disputes: When Agreements Go Awry

Contracts are a fundamental element of countless business dealings. These legally binding agreements outline the terms and obligations agreed upon by two or more parties. However, situations can arise when one party fails to fulfill their end of the bargain. This results in what is known as a breach of contract.

Imagine you've signed a contract with a supplier for raw materials. These materials are crucial to your manufacturing process. However, the supplier fails to deliver on time and in the agreed-upon quantities. This throws your entire production schedule off track, potentially causing significant financial losses. This scenario represents a common example of why businesses turn to litigation for a solution.

In other instances, disagreements may occur regarding the interpretation of specific clauses within a contract. This can lead to disputes about payment terms, deadlines, or the scope of work agreed upon. A business litigation lawyer can help resolve these types of legal issues.

Business partnerships can be incredibly rewarding. They bring together individuals with complementary skills and a shared vision. But just like any relationship, partnerships can encounter problems. This can lead to disputes that require legal action.

Common Causes of Partnership Litigation:

  • **Breach of Partnership Agreements**: Similar to contractual disputes, issues may occur if a partner fails to abide by the terms outlined in the partnership agreement. These agreements usually cover vital aspects of the business partnership, such as:
    • Profit-sharing
    • Responsibilities
    • Decision-making processes
    • What happens if a partner wishes to exit the partnership.
  • **Shareholder Oppression**: In situations where one shareholder or a group of shareholders acts in a way that unfairly disadvantages other shareholders, litigation might be the only path toward resolution. Examples of shareholder disputes could include:
    • Diverting company funds for personal gain.
    • Making crucial decisions without proper consultation or consent from minority shareholders.
    • Attempting to force certain shareholders out of the business unfairly.

Dissolving Partnerships When All Else Fails

When disagreements become insurmountable and parties can no longer see eye-to-eye on how to move forward, partnership dissolution might be the only option. Partnership dissolution involves legally dissolving the business relationship. Assets and liabilities are divided as outlined in the partnership agreement or as determined by the court.

Dissolving a business partnership as a result of a partnership dispute is an intricate process. It necessitates a skilled legal guide who understands partnership laws. Our business litigation lawyers can help ensure each party receives their rightful due. An experienced attorney can determine if alternative dispute resolution is a possibility. They will know whether it makes more sense to pursue litigation law.

Shielding Your Innovations: The Battle Over Intellectual Property

In today's knowledge-based economy, safeguarding intellectual property (IP) has become paramount. Protecting your intangible assets is critical to maintaining a competitive edge. Intellectual property can include:

  • Innovative products
  • Proprietary technologies
  • Unique brand identities
  • Confidential business information

But what is business litigation in relation to intellectual property? Business litigation often arises when a company believes that its intellectual property rights have been infringed upon. Examples of IP that are commonly the source of legal action include:

  • **Trademarks**: These distinctive symbols, logos, or phrases identify a company's products or services. For example, think of the iconic Apple logo or the distinctive swoosh of Nike. These are common types of intellectual property that companies litigate over.
  • **Patents**: Granted for inventions that meet specific criteria such as novelty, usefulness, and non-obviousness. For instance, securing a patent on a groundbreaking medical device or a new manufacturing process could offer significant legal protection.
  • **Trade Secrets**: Often providing a competitive advantage because of their confidential nature. This can encompass manufacturing processes, customer lists, marketing strategies, or recipes like the closely guarded recipe of Coca-Cola. Businesses often implement rigorous confidentiality agreements to protect such information.

Let's illustrate a real-world example involving a business dispute related to shareholder oppression and its potential ramifications:

In a 2015 Michigan case, *Madugula v. Taub*, the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that violating the rights and interests stipulated in a shareholder's agreement can indeed serve as evidence of shareholder oppression. Such situations underscore why understanding the complexities of business relationships, particularly shareholder agreements and fiduciary duties, proves invaluable.

If you suspect someone is infringing on your company's trademark, patent, copyright, or trade secrets, seeking the advice of an experienced business litigation attorney is crucial. A litigation lawyer can assess the situation. We can also advise you on your legal options, and, if necessary, help you file a lawsuit. This will help you protect your intellectual property and seek compensation for damages.

Protecting Yourself and Your Business From Costly Litigation

Navigating through complex business litigation might seem daunting. Understanding the core reasons behind such disputes can be empowering. Here are some steps to help you protect your interests:

  1. **Solid Agreements**: When entering into partnerships or contractual arrangements, make sure the agreements are thorough, comprehensive, and reviewed by legal professionals. Clear and concise language in contracts helps avoid misinterpretations and disputes down the line. Litigation lawyers can provide legal counsel on business decisions before they become contractual obligations.
  2. **Document Everything**: Maintain thorough documentation related to financial transactions, contracts, communications with partners or competitors, and any agreements pertaining to intellectual property. This paper trail proves invaluable if a dispute arises. Documentation is especially important regarding employment issues like wrongful termination. It's also crucial in insurance coverage disputes to maintain good faith with the insurance company.
  3. **Alternative Dispute Resolution** Alternative dispute resolution offers methods for resolving business disputes outside of the traditional court system. This includes methods like mediation and arbitration.
    • Mediation, for instance, involves enlisting a neutral third party to guide the parties toward a mutually acceptable agreement. Experienced attorneys will often recommend mediation in an attempt to avoid the cost and time commitment of a trial.
    • Arbitration, similarly, relies on a neutral third party (or a panel of arbitrators). However, in this case, they render a binding decision. 
  4. **Seek Legal Counsel**: Consider proactively consulting with a legal professional who specializes in business law. They can provide guidance, review contracts, and alert you to potential red flags that could expose your business to litigation risks. This is especially true with employment litigation. Federal laws change frequently so it's best to get the advice of an employment litigation attorney.

When conflicts arise despite these preventative measures, remember that litigation might be necessary to protect your rights. Finding an experienced litigation attorney becomes extremely important. It's good to work with someone familiar with commercial law. Ideally, they should be familiar with the unique challenges presented by the industry you operate within. For instance, if your legal issue stems from your business partnership, you may want to hire a commercial litigation attorney who specializes in business partnership disputes.

Understanding Common Business Torts and Their Impact

Sometimes, companies engage in unethical or wrongful acts that, while not necessarily criminal, can harm other businesses or individuals. These situations are where business torts come into play. Here are a few notable types of business torts to be aware of:

  • **Tortious Interference**: This tort often involves a third party meddling in a business's contractual relationships or prospective business opportunities. This ultimately leads to financial harm. It underscores how external factors can impact a business's success and profitability.
  • **Fraudulent Misrepresentation**: When someone makes false statements intending to deceive a business into entering into a detrimental agreement, they might be liable for fraudulent misrepresentation.
  • **Unfair Competition**: Laws exist to prevent companies from engaging in deceptive or anti-competitive practices. These are practices aimed at unfairly gaining an advantage over competitors. Examples of this could include making discrimination claims to damage the reputation of a competitor.

Understanding potential litigation triggers and effective risk management strategies provides businesses with valuable tools. These tools will help them thrive in the face of complexities inherent in the world of commerce. Now you understand, What is business litigation? Let's review some frequently asked questions.

FAQs about What is business litigation?

What is the meaning of business litigation?

Business litigation, often called commercial litigation, handles legal battles in the business world. It involves going to court to resolve disagreements. These disagreements can be related to many things. Some examples include:

  • Broken contracts
  • Problems between business partners
  • Arguments over intellectual property (like trademarks and patents)
  • When someone claims a business did something wrong that hurt them. For instance, they could claim there was wrongful action regarding medical leave or hour disputes

Instead of just talking it out, businesses sometimes have to use the legal system to find a fair solution. An experienced attorney has likely handled many different litigation cases. They'll know the best way to resolve the situation, whether it be through alternative dispute resolution, filing a lawsuit in federal court, or some other legal action.

What is general business litigation?

"General business litigation" covers many disputes businesses might face. This category basically encompasses any conflict where one business sues another for some perceived harm or violation of its rights. This could be from things like agreement breaches, or bad faith dealings.

Unlike specialized areas like employment or intellectual property law, general business litigation is broader. It includes common types of legal issues, such as:

  • Problems with contracts (like one party not keeping their word)
  • Torts (meaning one business claiming another did something wrong)
  • Unfair competition
  • Partnership issues
  • Conflicts between shareholders and companies

What is the most common business litigation?

Breach of contract lawsuits take the crown as the most frequently seen business litigation. Contracts form the backbone of countless business interactions. When a disagreement arises—perhaps one side fails to deliver as promised or argues over interpreting terms—it often lands in court. It can even include things that impact employees, like an employer failing to meet contractual obligations for wages or medical leave.

What does it mean if a company is in litigation?

"Being in litigation" simply means a company is entangled in a lawsuit. It might be suing another entity or person, being sued by them, or both. Someone could even be pursuing legal action against a company for illegal activity. This usually happens when parties hit a wall in resolving a dispute. This often leads to seeking intervention from the courts to reach a solution. For instance, a class representative might bring class action lawsuits on behalf of many people against a company for issues such as data breaches. The law recognizes this type of legal action as a class action and the lawsuits are called class action lawsuits.

Conclusion

So, what is business litigation? It's essentially the process of resolving disputes in a court setting. Disputes that result in business litigation can range from breach of contract cases and partnership disagreements to intellectual property battles and class action lawsuits. Navigating these turbulent waters demands knowledge and awareness.

With solid contracts, comprehensive documentation, and an experienced legal team, businesses can navigate the complexities of commercial disputes, safeguard their interests, and position themselves for long-term success.

About the Author

Darrell P. White

Darrell P. White is a business trial lawyer specializing in complex business disputes across a myriad of industries and a partner at Kimura London & White LLP. His clients include large corporations and institutions generating billions in revenue annually, multinational corporations, and entrepreneurs.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Irvine Office

17631 Fitch, Irvine,
CA 92614
Google Maps

Beverly Hills Office

9171 Wilshire Blvd, Suite 500,
Beverly Hills, CA 90210
Google Maps

Menu